A lot of people are just plain wrong about workers’ compensation, especially when it comes to gig workers like an Instacart shopper who gets a concussion in Boston. They think these cases are either a slam dunk or a total dead end, but the truth is it’s complicated. Getting the benefits you deserve means you have to understand how to use Massachusetts workers’ comp law to fight for them.
Key Takeaways
- Instacart shoppers and other gig workers can get workers’ compensation benefits in Massachusetts, but only if they can be legally classified as employees, not independent contractors.
- A concussion is a serious brain injury, and it absolutely qualifies for workers’ comp, which would cover medical bills, pay for time you can’t work, and maybe job retraining.
- Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 152 controls the whole system and has very specific deadlines for reporting an injury and filing a claim.
- Insurance companies deny claims from gig workers all the time. This is normal, and you have to appeal through the Department of Industrial Accidents.
- Winning your case comes down to proving you were an employee and that your injury happened while you were on the clock.
Myth 1: Instacart Shoppers Are Always Independent Contractors and Can’t Get Workers’ Comp
The biggest myth that stops injured Instacart shoppers cold is that they’re independent contractors with no rights. Instacart calls you an independent contractor, sure, but Massachusetts law often disagrees, and that’s what really matters. The state uses one of the toughest “ABC tests” in the country to figure out if you’re an employee. According to Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 149, Section 148B, you’re automatically considered an employee unless the company can prove all three of these things: (A) you are totally free from their control and direction in how you do your job; (B) the work you do is outside their usual line of business. And (C) you have your own independently established business doing that same kind of work. Instacart has a hell of a time proving all three parts of that test. For instance, they control your work through delivery windows and rating systems. The work you do, delivering groceries, is exactly Instacart’s business. And proving you run your own “independently established” delivery business just because you might also drive for Uber is a very high legal bar for them to clear. Time and again, Massachusetts courts have reclassified gig workers as employees. Getting reclassified as an employee is everything. If an Instacart shopper slips on ice and gets a concussion delivering to a brownstone in the North End, their right to benefits depends on winning this classification fight, not on the label Instacart gave them.
Myth 2: A Concussion Isn’t a “Serious Enough” Injury for Workers’ Comp
People think you need a bone sticking out of your arm to get workers’ comp, but that’s just wrong. A brain injury like a concussion is serious and it is absolutely covered. A concussion is a traumatic brain injury (TBI) that happens when a jolt or hit makes your brain slam around inside your skull. The CDC is very clear that concussions are serious injuries that can cause long-term problems like headaches, memory loss, and an inability to concentrate. These symptoms can make it impossible for someone to do their job. Massachusetts workers’ comp law (M.G.L. c. 152) covers any personal injury that happens “arising out of and in the course of employment.” Concussions are included. The real work is in documenting the symptoms and proving how they affect you, especially since you might not have blacked out or had a visible cut. You need medical evidence from neurologists and other doctors that spells out the diagnosis (like Post-Concussion Syndrome) and explains the specific ways it stops you from being able to earn a living. An Instacart shopper has to think fast, navigate busy streets, and lift heavy things. How can you do that with a concussion? A successful claim is built on documenting every single thing, the persistent headaches, the sensitivity to light, the trouble focusing. That’s what wins cases.
Injured on the job?
3 in 5 injured workers never receive their full benefits. Your employer’s insurer is not on your side.
Myth 3: You Have Plenty of Time to File a Claim After a Work Injury
Don’t sleep on the deadlines. They’re real and they can kill your claim before it even gets started. While Massachusetts law gives you some time, any delay can put your case in danger, especially with a concussion where your symptoms might not even show up for a few days. Under M.G.L. c. 152, Section 41, you have to tell your employer about your injury “as soon as practicable,” which generally means within 30 days. If you miss that window, you could be barred from getting benefits unless you have a very good reason for the delay. After giving notice, you have to file a formal claim (Form 110) with the Department of Industrial Accidents (DIA). The absolute deadline is four years from the injury date, but you should never, ever wait that long. Waiting just gives the insurance company an opening to argue that your injury didn’t happen at work or that you’re faking it. If you’re an Instacart shopper who fell delivering groceries near Boston Common, you need to report it to Instacart immediately (even if they’ll fight you on being an “employer”) and get to a doctor. Any delay just makes it harder to get paid.
Myth 4: If the Insurance Company Denies Your Claim, It’s Over
An initial denial letter from the insurance company is not the end of your case. In fact, it’s usually just the beginning of the real fight. Insurers deny claims all the time, especially for gig workers or for injuries like concussions that aren’t obvious at a glance. Their job is to save money, and denying claims is step one. In Massachusetts, a denial just means you have to appeal it at the Department of Industrial Accidents. The process involves:
- Conciliation: An informal meeting where you try to work out a deal.
- Conference: A more formal step in front of a judge, who makes an initial order.
- Hearing: If either side appeals the conference order, you have a full-blown trial with evidence and testimony.
- Reviewing Board: You can appeal the hearing decision to a panel of judges at the DIA.
- Appeals Court: From there, cases can go to the state Appeals Court.
At every step, you get another chance to present your medical records, your testimony, and legal arguments to prove your case. Plenty of claims that get denied at first end up getting approved after going through this appeals process. You just have to stick with it. For the Instacart shopper hit by a car in the Seaport District, the denial letter is where the battle starts, not where it ends.
Myth 5: You Can Handle a Workers’ Comp Claim on Your Own, Especially with a Concussion
While you technically can represent yourself, trying to handle a complex workers’ comp claim on your own is a terrible idea. Trying to do it while recovering from a brain injury is just asking for disaster. The symptoms of a concussion, confusion, memory problems, fatigue, make it nearly impossible to deal with the mountain of legal paperwork, strict deadlines, and negotiations with professional insurance adjusters. The Massachusetts workers’ comp system is a maze of specific rules, legal precedents, and procedures. A good workers’ comp attorney knows how to get the right medical evidence (like neurocognitive test results), how to present it to a judge, how to cross-examine the insurer’s doctors, and how to fight for all the benefits you’re owed, including weekly pay, medical coverage, and job retraining. They also know how to win the critical fight over your employee status as a gig worker. You’re up against an insurance company that has a team of lawyers. You need one on your side, too. Getting workers’ compensation for a concussion as an Instacart shopper in Boston is a tough fight, but it’s a fight you can win. It means understanding the employee classification rules, proving the seriousness of your brain injury, hitting every deadline, and being ready to appeal a denial. It’s a journey, and you have to be ready to push back against a system that’s not built to be easy.
What benefits can an Instacart shopper get for a work-related concussion in Massachusetts?
If you’re classified as an employee, you can get a few key things. First, the insurer has to pay for all reasonable and necessary medical care for your concussion, which includes everything from the ER visit and MRIs to specialized physical and cognitive therapy. Second, you can get weekly checks to replace the wages you’ve lost (either temporary total disability or partial disability benefits). Finally, if your injury is bad enough that you can’t go back to being a shopper, you could get vocational rehabilitation services to help you find a new line of work.
How does the law define “arising out of and in the course of employment” for a gig worker’s concussion?
For your concussion to be covered, it has to be directly connected to your work for Instacart. This means it must have happened while you were actively doing your job, shopping in the store, driving to the customer’s house, or walking up their steps to make the delivery. If you got hurt while running a personal errand between orders or before you even logged on, it’s probably not going to be covered. The specific details of what you were doing at the exact moment of injury are everything.
What medical documents are most important for a concussion claim?
You need a strong paper trail. This starts with the first report from the ER or urgent care. After that, you need reports from specialists like neurologists, results from any neuropsychological testing that shows cognitive problems, and ongoing notes from therapists. All these records must clearly connect your symptoms back to the work incident and explain exactly what you can and can’t do because of the injury.
If Instacart disputes my employee status, what happens to my claim?
When Instacart disputes your employee status, their insurance carrier will deny your claim. That’s when you have to file a formal claim at the Department of Industrial Accidents (DIA). The main event in your case, through conciliation and then a conference with a judge, will be the fight over whether you’re an employee under the Massachusetts ABC test (M.G.L. c. 149, Section 148B). This is a legal battle, and it’s where most of these cases are won or lost.
Can I still get workers’ comp if my concussion symptoms didn’t show up right away?
Yes. It’s common for concussion symptoms to be delayed, sometimes by hours or days. The most important thing is to report the incident itself (the fall, the car accident, etc.) to Instacart as soon as it happens, even if you feel fine. Then, as soon as you start feeling symptoms, you need to see a doctor and tell them about the earlier incident. Your medical records need to show the timeline and make the connection between the work event and your delayed symptoms.